Dec 16, 2011
Trust operations began in the Philippines in 1918 upon the establishment of a corporation called Philippine Trust Company, to administer and manage the properties of Americans during their early occupation of the Philippines. Since then, trust operations gradually emerged as one of the more popular services being offered by banks. It was however from 1983 to 1991 where the industry experienced remarkable growth, from P18 billion in 1983 to about P37 billion in 1986, and then reached the P100 billion mark in 1991. The Industry then moved on to grow in the 90s into a multibillion industry - as the public becomes more aware of the more sophisticated Asset and Trust Management services available.
This P700B industry is not however reflected in the total resources of the Banking Industry. This is consistent with the industry’s off-balance sheet nature, as these figures are carried and remain to be direct assets instead of the Banks' trust clients as its real and/or beneficial owners. As such, Assets Held in Trust or those received by the bank in its fiduciary capacity (collectively referred to as: ‘AHIT’) may not be looked upon for recovery by any of the Bank’s creditors (depositors) anytime. Consistent with the latter, unlike traditional banking products, products and services offered through the bank’s trust department do not, and can not carry any bank guarantee in terms of investment return on principal nor are required to be covered by a PDIC guarantee. Thus, true to its business trade, the industry is primarily premised on their respective client’s “trust” to the said financial institution. Because of its inherent nature, the industry is mandated to be conducted clearly independent from that of the bank’s traditional deposit-taking activities. An independent Trust Officer with no less than 2 years experience in the business is mandated by law to report directly only to a duly constituted Trust Committee (composed of the Trust Officer himself, the Banks President, and 3 Bank Board Directors on a rotation basis), who in turn reports directly to the Bank’s Board of Directors. Moreover, safeguards consistent with the fiduciary obligation of banks to their clients are put in place to protect the investing public.
The Industry offers a myriad of products designed primarily to the investment requirements of the more sophisticated clientele demanding more specific fund management customization but without the traditional bank guaranty of return. The more popular products available through TOAP's member-institutions are:
Although not an obligation of the Trust Entity and not insured with the Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation, money placed with a reputable trust entity is just as safe, if not safer, than money in a savings or time deposit account with a bank. There are enough safeguards instituted through current government regulations and industry practice.
Under a circular issued by the Monetary Board, an applicant for a trust and investment management license must have a combined capital account of not less than P250 million.
Before a trust entity with trust license can actually accept money in trust, an initial deposit of at least P500,000.00 with the BSP, in the form of eligible government securities, as security for the trust entity's faithful performance of its trust duties is likewise required. If assets managed exceeds P50 Million, the trust entity must place with the BSP additional government securities to maintain its deposit at the equivalent of at least 1.0% of total value of assets managed. This deposit likewise serves as security that the trust entity will perform its duties well. At no time can the security deposit be less than P500,000.00.
Under this rule, the trust entity is required to "administer the funds or property under its custody with the skill, care, prudence and diligence necessary under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man, acting in like capacity and familiar with such matters, would exercise in the conduct of an enterprise of a like character and with similar aims".
The BSP regulations on trust and investment management spell out some of the specifics of the Prudent-Man rule in a set of investment rules that limit the placement of funds and upholds disclosure and transparency in investments.
Informative reports are required to be made by the trustee to the client and other parties who have legitimate interest in the trust. These reports must be given at least quarterly, and must consist of a balance sheet, an income statement, a schedule of earning assets and an investment activity report. The trust entity likewise submits to the BSP periodic reports on the trustee's trust business.
The trust entity is required to submit itself to an annual triple audit: one by its own internal auditors, a second by the independent external auditors of the trust entity, and the third by the examiners of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. These audits, which have the common purpose of determining whether the trust business of the financial institution is being conducted in accordance with the law and regulations, serve as effective deterrents against unsound practices and fraudulent schemes.
Trust assets are required to be kept separate and distinct from all other assets of the trust entity's business; trust books and records are separate and independent from other books and records of the trust entity. The records of each trust account are separate from those of all other accounts and are adequately identified.
No assets held by the trust entity as trustee shall be subject to any claims other than those of the parties (trustor/beneficiaries) interested in the specific trust accounts.
No single person controls the entire process of administration of a trust /investment management fund. The Board of Directors, the Trust Committee and the Trust Officer are all involved. Normally, transactions involving the trust account require dual signatories for implementation and trust assets are under the joint custody of at least two persons, one of whom shall be an officer of the trust entity, designated for that purpose by the Board of Directors.
The fees are based on the cost of services rendered and the responsibilities assumed; not based on the excess of the income derived from the investment of trust fund over a certain amount of percentage.
No respectable trust entity would want to have its name sullied by scandals and scams perpetrated by its own people. Every trust entity now operating would like, instead, to develop and maintain a reputation of prudent investment and efficient administration. A trust entity worthy of its name "Trust", works hard to ensure that always make sure that the client's account is safe, that it achieves reasonable growth for the funds it manages and that its accounts yield adequate income for its clients.
| TRUST SERVICES | BANKING TRANSACTIONS |
|---|---|
| On Relationship Trust services basically make the institution a manager of the client's assets, either as trustee, agent, custodian, or advisor. |
On Relationship Banking transactions with banks or other financial institutions almost always involve a creditor/debtor relationship. The depositor/investor effectively extends a loan (deposit) to the financial institution. |
| On Documentation The documentation of the trust transaction is usually in the form of trust indentures, investment management agreements, custodian contracts or investment advisory agreements. |
On Documentation The clients are given a passbook, certificate of deposits, repurchase agreements or confirmation of sale evidencing the deposit of placement. |
| On Duties The essential duty of the trust institution is to do its best in getting the best deal for the client. Thus, when funds held in trust are invested, the trustee is required to put money in an investment that gives the highest income compatible with the safety of the capital. |
On Duties The duty of the financial institution is merely to pay back the client's money with the agreed interest at the agreed maturity date. |
| On Liabilities If the money placed in an investment, which in spite of the due care and prudence exercised by the asset manager, result in a loss, the loss is borne by the client himself. The investor's money is not covered by the PDIC insurance. However, adequate protection is secured by strict laws and regulations concerning trust activities. In case of a bank closure, the trust department continues to collect on existing investments and/or delivers assets/securities back to clients or successor trustees or agents. |
On Liabilities If the depositor's money is placed by the financial institution in a losing investment, the loss is borne by the financial institution itself. In financial institutions, only deposits up to P100,000 are insured with the PDIC. As for the excess, the ability of the institution to return the client's money depends on the institution's own financial standing. |
Trust fund constitutes all property placed under trust which includes money, securities, and real as well as personal property. A trust fund is created for the purpose of administering the property for the use of benefit of the trustor or of others. Because of this, trust funds do not form part of the bank's assets and are thus classified as contingent accounts.
Also, the administration of trust funds is done on a best-effort basis. Hence, no interest rate can be guaranteed. The trustee does not promise a result, instead he offers his assistance to achieve the desired result.
The trustee does not do business with the client, as in the case of depositor-bank business; like an agent, he is doing business for a client.
Money market normally refers to types of financial transactions involving the sale purchase of debt instruments with varying maturities. Being debt instruments, these securities usually involve fixed interest.
In trust instruments, however, the trust fund may be placed in the money market. This however, does not convert the trust itself into a debt instrument carrying a fixed interest rate. Money market is merely an investment outlet for trust funds.
Trusteeship is an arrangement whereby a trustor transfers property to a trustee for the latter to administer in a certain manner, for the benefit of the trustor or third persons (beneficiary). Agency is an arrangement whereby a person binds himself to render some service on behalf of another with the consent or authority of the latter.
The distinguishing characteristic of trusteeship from agency is that in the case of trust the kind of transfer required is a peculiar transfer of the entire legal title or ownership to the trustee subject only to the latter's duty to hold it for the beneficiary as directed by the trustor. Thus, while trustee is vested with the legal title to the property, the agent is vested only with the power to perform certain acts regarding the property without having any legal title to it; only some attributes of ownership are delegated to the agent by the property owner.
Despite legal distinction between trusteeship from agency, in practice, however, the scope of activities under trusteeship and agency is basically the same. Thus, most trust corporations or trust departments of banks now include agency as a type of service.
The relationship of guardian and ward, and that of trustee and trust beneficiary, bear considerable similarity to each other. A guardian is under a duty to deal with the ward's property for the benefit of the ward, and hence serves in a fiduciary relationship.
However, there is a sharp distinction between the position of a guardian and that of a trustee, one that is of real importance in connection with sound estate planning, and one that apparently is seldom understood in the making of estate plans. This distinction comes from the fact that while a guardian is entrusted with the possession and management of his ward's property, he does not take legal title to that property; it belongs to him, and title is in his name (not that of the guardian).
Since the trustee takes legal title to trust property, he may sue or be sued in his own name as trustee for a certain trust property.
The two relationships are markedly different from each other, and the guardian, ordinarily subject to orders of the court, will not have, and usually cannot be given, the same powers that can be given to a trustee under a properly prepared trust instrument.
Both trust and mutual funds can act as investment vehicles to ensure long term growth of assets. The difference in the structure of both instruments, however, implies a wide difference in the flexibility afforded to investors. Trust funds are constructed with the needs and constraints of a specific investor in mind. Investment policies can be easily adjusted to adapt to changing investor needs and the variable investment climate.
Mutual funds, on the other hand, represent passive ownership of shares of an investment company. Investment policies and strategies are pre-approved by the appropriate regulatory body to cater to a large number of investors in a specific segment. The composition of the fund and its strategies cannot be tailored to the needs of any one investor.
Trust funds also have a broader scope as to the disposition of the assets. A trust fund can distribute assets to beneficiaries in a scheme specified by the trustor. A trust fund, for instance, can be set up to pay for grandchildren's education. The trustee can take it upon itself to schedule maturities to meet scheduled tuition fee payments. Mutual fund servicing only covers the buying and redemption (selling) of mutual fund shares; the service does not include the systematic distribution of the mutual funds proceeds to the investor's beneficiaries.
The life of a corporation or institution is almost perpetual. The investor/client feels assured that the institutional trustee/investment manager he chooses will continue to be in existence and be prepared to serve his needs as well as his beneficiaries of the second and even the third generation.
In the trust entity, continuity of capacity is to be found in the succession of trust officers. Incapacity or unavailability of one trust officer handling the account does not disrupt the servicing of the account because in a normal corporate set up, a successor or replacement or substitute immediately takes over.
The management of assets is the work, not of one, but of several specialists. Thus, there are specialists, for example, in the investment of trust funds; in the management of business; in bookkeeping and accounting; in tax work; in research, in documentation, or even specialization and focus in terms of investment outlets (fixed income, global, equities, etc.)
The trust entity obtains the group judgment of its officers, its Trust Committee and its Board of Directors (or other specialized units depending on the internal structure of a particular institution).
The trust entity is under constant and continuous government regulations, examination and supervision by various government entities, specifically the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas, to ensure that the trust entity manages assets held in the best interest of its beneficiary.
The institutional trustee is financially responsible not only by its own capital and surplus but also by the reserves it is required to put up for its trust business. Unlike a natural person as trustee, an institutional trustee is more compelled to maintain its financial responsiveness, otherwise it may forfeit the patronage of people seeking its professional services.
Trust is a legal device or arrangement whereby a person delivers part or all of his properties to another person who administers and manages the property/ies for the benefit of designated person/s. The term "person" could mean an individual or natural person or a juridical entity like a corporation or institution.
It is an arrangement composed of three parties, each with his own rights and obligations, and a variety of properties and interests intended to serve a multitude of ends and purposes.
The distinguishing feature of a trust is found in the fact that the legal title to property is in one person, while the beneficial interest (usually referred to as the "equitable title") is in another person. The legal rights of ownership and control are in the trustee, subject to the duty of using and applying the property as directed by the trustor, while the right to enjoy the benefits from the property is in the trust beneficiary.
Trust may be implied or express. Implied trust is created by operation of law, as for example when a person acquires property by mistake, he is considered by the law as a trustee while he holds the same for the real owner of the property. Express trust is established by the intention of the parties or of the trustor.
The person creating the trust must expressly show that he really intended a trust arrangement. Imperfect expression of intent may result in converting the arrangement into some other form of management or simple agency relationship.
This is the subject matter of the trust. The property to be conveyed in trust must be existing, lawful, definite and transferable. Anything that has an economic value and which a person may own and to which he may transfer legal title, by gift or sale, is a property that may be conveyed in trust.
Thus, a trust may be constituted on real estate, household effects, cash, stocks, bonds and other securities, livestock and growing crops, works of art, jewelry and other tangible things.
Trust property need not be a tangible thing; it may be comprised of a claim, such as a right of action for breach of contract or upon a promissory note. For instance, a trust may exist in life insurance policies or the proceeds thereof; or may consists of patents, copyrights, goodwill, trademarks and trade secrets.
If the trust violates a law or is against morals, public policy or public order, the trust will be void and of no effect. Thus, a trust will be void if it involves the commission of a criminal act by the trustee, or if the trustee encourages the neglect of parental duties, restrains marriage, religious freedom or the performance of public duties.
The trust instrument must at least show the following:
As its name implies, it is a trust whereby the trustor transfers his property in trust through his will and testament and this is to take effect only upon his death. It is a part of the will and testament itself and is not a separate legal document.
This is for clients who intend to accumulate all their assets as may be allowed by law into one fund to be managed by a competent and responsible trustee, specially if the trustor feels that he will be survived by heirs who would still be minors, or who are incapacitated or not competent to manage their own affairs or the properties they stand to inherit from the trustor. This prevents the unnecessary division of the trustor's estate and the consequent loss of earning power through unwise management or dissipation. Depending on how it is drafted, the testamentary trust can also minimize or avoid a second tax on the family estate as it is transferred from the surviving spouse to the children.
This trust, which is created by a trust agreement, starts to operate during the lifetime of the trustor. Under this arrangement, the trustor transfer assets to a trustee for the latter to manage as the trust agreement dictates. The functions and authorities to be exercised by the trustee are defined in the trust agreement. These would include: (1) the scope or extent of the trustee's investment powers; (2) the beneficiaries; (3) the terms and conditions under which the income and/or principal of the trust is to be paid or to be disposed of ultimately.
A living trust may either be revocable or irrevocable.
This is a form of a living trust whereby the trustor does not reserve the right to get trust property but requires its automatic return to him after the lapse of a certain period or upon the happening of a condition.
For instance, a well-to-do child might wish to set up a trust some of his income-producing properties for the support of his aged mother for as long as he lives. Upon the death of his mother, the trust properties will be returned to him by the trustee. No donor's tax is involved but the properties remain part of the gross estate of the trustor should he die during the term of the trust. The income, as in the case of an irrevocable trust, is no longer taxed to the trustor.
Direct payment of the insured's life insurance proceeds to his beneficiaries may be unwise if they are experienced or not inclined to manage the insurance proceeds. Through a life insurance trust, the insured/trustor appoints the trustee to receive or collect the trustor's life insurance proceeds. The trustee then invests and manages the fund for the benefit of the insured's family or other beneficiaries. The management of the life insurance proceeds and the eventual distribution thereof to the beneficiaries shall be in accordance with the terms set down by the trustor/insured in the life insurance trust agreement.
The beneficiaries may be designated as either revocable or irrevocable. In the case of revocable designation, the insurance proceeds will form part of the insured's life insurance proceeds.
In this type of trust, the trust agreement is executed before the property is actually transferred to the trustee.
This is a variant of the dry trust. Under this arrangement, the trustee holds no property until the happening of a certain event. For instance, a person may wish to set up a trust for his children that will take effect only when he becomes incapacitated or unable to support them. In the meantime, he continues to manage property. The trust remains dormant or "dry" until the trustee is informed that the trustor has become incapacitated and thus can no longer manage the property himself. The trustee then "steps up" into the action and manages the property for the trustor's children.
Under this arrangement, beneficiaries are designated successively. For instance, a father may set up a trust for his own son who is to receive the income of the trust for as long as he lives. The son is the "life tenant" or "income beneficiary". Upon the death of the son, the trust provides for the payment of the income to the grandson who will later receive the principal of the trust after say, reaching the age of 25. The grandson is called the "principal beneficiary" or the "remainderman". The estate tax that would have been paid had the son inherited the property outright is avoided when the son dies, effectively skipping taxation of the estate of one generation.
The trustee is under a direction by the trustor to keep the income of the trust fund within the trust and hold it for future distribution to the beneficiary.
For example, parents who wish to make sure that their child will have enough funds to enable him go to college would do well to set up an accumulation trust while the child is still very young. The income of the trust property is kept in the trust and is distributed to the child as soon as he goes to college.
The trustor gives the trustee sufficient authority to decide whether to accumulate or distribute the trust assets in accordance with the requirements of the beneficiary.
A trustor who has two or more beneficiaries may find it difficult to ascertain the specific needs to each beneficiary. The trust arrangement is therefore designed to enable the trust fund to meet as much as possible all needs of all beneficiaries, giving the trustee the power to decide how much to give to each beneficiary, not necessarily equally but according to need.
This trust prohibits the beneficiary from transferring or assigning his interest in the trust property prior to the actual distribution of the income or principal to him. It likewise prohibits him from assigning his interest in the property as a collateral loans. It effectively prevents an ingenious or gullible beneficiary from prematurely spending away his interest by excessive borrowings or assignments of his future interests in the trust assets.
Under this arrangement, the funds are set aside in a trust designed to motivate the beneficiary into accomplishing something (e.g., obtaining a college degree), upon the occurrence of which the trust funds are distributed to the beneficiary.
This is primarily an advisory service whereby the institutional trustee assists the client in developing a comprehensive financial plan designed to conserve, make productive, increase the value and eventually transfer the client's assets to his beneficiaries, at the least tax and other transfer costs. It is a multi-discipline activity requiring the participation not only of the institutional trustee, but also of others, like the client's insurance adviser, his pre-need counselor, his accountant and, always, his lawyer. Only a few institutional trustees extend this form of advisory service in its full range.
All these uses of trust for personal purposes must be thoroughly discussed not only with one's banker, but also, with others familiar with the trust device. One should consult his lawyer, accountant, investment advisor and even family friends and relatives.
The personal uses of trust are limitless. A combination of two or more of the above types is also feasible and desirable.
A bank, investment house or any corporation can be an institutional trustee, provided that it is duly authorized or licensed by the Monetary Board of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas to perform trust and fiduciary business.
In the case of authorized banks or investment houses, the trust or fiduciary business is normally carried out through their Trust division, department, group, unit, section, or any other form of aggrupation. In the case of trust companies or trust corporations, the entire company or corporation is involved in carrying out the trust or fiduciary business, precisely because the company is established for this particular business.
For the purposes of this Primer the words "trustee", "trust entity", or "institutional trustee", which have the same meaning and are interchangeable, shall refer to any of the authorized entities as described above, and the term "financial institution" shall refer to either a bank or an investment house.
Trust is flexible such that it can be modified from time to time to suit changing situations and objectives. However, certain limitations are to be considered and observed:
In any trust arrangement, however, the trustor and, in some cases the beneficiary, can change the trustee at any time.
The creation of a trust or the availment of certain trust services entails some expense like trust fees, but the amount of expense is really very nominal specially when compared to the benefits derived therefrom.
Trust fees should in fact be of at least concern to the trustor or client. To begin with, trust fees are always subject to review by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas and are kept in line by sheer competition from institutions similarly offering these services. In trust arrangements which have to pass through the Courts, the trust fees are subject to court approval. The fees can also be covered by the earnings of the trust itself such that, as in most trust arrangements, the trustor or client will not have to pay out the fees from his own pocket.
As a general rule, trust fees are quoted depending on the nature and scope of services the trustee will have to perform. Therefore, it is first necessary to have a preliminary discussion of the needs and specifications of the clients so as to arrive at a reasonable and fair estimate of the corresponding fees. Accordingly, the fees can vary and may be further adjusted and modified on a case-to-case basis.
In addition to the trust fees, all reasonable and necessary expenses incurred by the trustee in the administration of the trust are for the account of the client. The trust fees and/or administrative expenses may be charged to the fund itself or directly to the client, depending on the agreement between the trustee and the client, or on the policies of the client and/or the trustee, or on the type of services availed of.